At 15.5 per cent, India has one of the lowest tax-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratios, says a recent paper by the Centre for Budget and Governance Accountability. Even lower middle-income countries had tax-GDP ratios of 17.7 per cent, the paper said.
Among G20 countries, India had the third-lowest tax base, before Mexico and Indonesia, the paper said. The 37.7 per cent share of direct taxes to India’s total taxes was lower and regressive compared to developing countries such as South Africa (57.5 per cent), Indonesia (55.85 per cent) and Russia (41.3 per cent). Developed G20 countries had a greater share of taxes as part of total tax revenues, the paper said, adding in the US, this stood at 75.8 per cent.
The property tax-to-GDP ratio in India is only 0.48 per cent; for France and the UK, it is 4.3 per cent and 4.21 per cent, respectively. For China, it is 1.7 per cent. Wealth tax in India is only 0.007 per cent of GDP, while it is 0.89 per cent in France.
In 2011-12, the tax-GDP ratio stood at 5.5 per cent for direct taxes and 4.4 per cent for indirect taxes. The finance minister P. Chidambaram had said that we can reclaim the peak rate of 11.9% in the FY 2007-08, adding that this is not enough to be on the path of inclusive growth and sustainable development
According to a report by Moody's, India's tax-to-GDP ratio, at just under 15 percent, is lower than countries with similar sovereign ratings. There are three key reasons for that.
One, structural factors such as low per capita income keeps tax collections low. "Low average incomes and a high poverty rate result in a very small portion of the labor force being eligible to pay personal income taxes. As of 2010-11, income taxes accounted for a lower proportion (10 percent) of the general government's revenue than, say, the OECD average (approximately 30 percent)," said Moody's.
Structural factors such as low per capita income keeps tax collections low. Reuters
Two, a large proportion of economic activity that is generated by small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Although these enterprises have enjoyed strong profitability growth over the past decade, the government has not captured their earnings in tax revenues due to a variety of exemptions and compliance issues, the ratings agency said.
Three, a lack of policy initiatives has also kept the tax take low." This includes certain tax exemptions on agriculture related activity and until the mid-nineties, on most services as well. The tax net has been progressively expanded to include a greater number of services each year, and service tax revenue has grown the fastest of all revenue sources. Yet, service taxes constitute merely 5 percent of total general government revenues, although they comprise about 60 percent of GDP," said Moody's.
Given these constraints, general government revenues have relied on manufactured goods (consumption and trade) and corporate profit taxes, which at the end of March 2011, accounted for 35 percent and 22 percent of general government revenues, respectively.
Both taxes are highly sensitive to growth trends. In 2008-09, corporate profits were hit by multiple shocks, including slowing domestic demand, heightened input costs domestic interest rates, and risk aversion limiting international capital availability (see chart above). These shocks led to a 5 percent decline in corporate tax revenues in 2008-09, from 39 percent growth in the previous year, said Moody's.
Source: Moody's
Indirect taxes also suffered from the slowdown in demand and manufacturing output, slowing from 20 percent growth in 2006-07 to 9 percent in 2007-08.
What does this mean for the future?
The trends above suggest that in the next two years, any attempt at fiscal consolidation (raising government revenues and cutting expenditure) will depend on how far corporate profits and consumption recover. Moody's expects India's tax-to-GDP ratio to recover from its current level of under 15 percent to 17 percent when GDP growth recovers and sustains at levels higher than 8 percent.
(All charts provided by Moody's)
No comments:
Post a Comment